Metabola [any]

  • 5 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 1st, 2020

help-circle


  • Oops I didn’t see you reposted here so I’ll post my response here as well.

    I can think of a a few reasons they would do this. Bhutan is an Indian vassal (although less so now than in the past) so this could put pressure on India to resolve their (China’s and India’s) border dispute. India has repeatedly refused very advantageous (for India) solutions like the Package Deal, proposed by China multiple times since 1960, where China gets Aksai Chin (with a civilian population of 0 and an area of 38,000 km2) and India gets Arunachal Pradesh (with a population of 1.4 million and an area of 83,743 km2).

    Another reason could be to pressure Bhutan directly for a number of reasons. It could be to get Bhutan to recognize China as a country, which it hasn’t done since the founding of the PRC (it doesn’t recognize the RoC either). It could be to get Bhutan to stop dragging it’s feet (in general it seems that feet-dragging is the default mode of operation of the Bhutanese government) with actually settling the border, which it has also never done. It could also be to get Bhutan to officially give up their claims on their former enclaves inside China, of which there are many, mostly in Tibet but iirc there are a few in other provinces (India also has at least one that it hasn’t given up claims on).

    I wrote most of this from memory and I’m not super well read on the topic so there are probably some inaccuracies.


  • Responding to PostingInternational@lemmygrad.ml’s comment in the last thread.

    I can think of a a few reasons they would do this. Bhutan is an Indian vassal (although less so now than in the past) so this could put pressure on India to resolve their (China’s and India’s) border dispute. India has repeatedly refused very advantageous (for India) solutions like the Package Deal, proposed by China multiple times since 1960, where China gets Aksai Chin (with a civilian population of 0 and an area of 38,000 km2) and India gets Arunachal Pradesh (with a population of 1.4 million and an area of 83,743 km2).

    Another reason could be to pressure Bhutan directly for a number of reasons. It could be to get Bhutan to recognize China as a country, which it hasn’t done since the founding of the PRC (it doesn’t recognize the RoC either). It could be to get Bhutan to stop dragging it’s feet (in general it seems that feet-dragging is the default mode of operation of the Bhutanese government) with actually settling the border, which it has also never done. It could also be to get Bhutan to officially give up their claims on their former enclaves inside China, of which there are many, mostly in Tibet but iirc there are a few in other provinces (India also has at least one that it hasn’t given up claims on).

    I wrote most of this from memory and I’m not super well read on the topic so there are probably some inaccuracies.