Not sure what to make of this. TikTokers’ first anti-imperialist “theory” being from a far-right anticommunist religious zealot with valid criticisms but no real analysis and a bit of “Jews control everything” seems perfect for the mainstream media to weaponize. On the other hand, people are realizing America are the bad guys and terrorists don’t hate us for our freedom, and will hopefully learn more, far better stuff?

Tiktok took the videos down but I screenshot these two comments lmfao: joker-laden

Edit:

CNN article (the thing I linked in the post was a video)

FOX News, NBC, New York Times, Forbes, Washington Post, the Guardian, Wall Street Journal, CBS, Reuters, TIME Magazine, The Hill, etc. all reported on it in the past few hours. You got headlines like “Bin Laden’s Letter to US Stuns Young Americans: ‘He Was Right’”

  • porcupine@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    26
    ·
    8 months ago

    I think “he was right” is a pretty understandable if reductive reaction to learning about his articulated motivations in his own words for the first time after being told their whole lives that the attack was unprovoked and motivated only by his personal fury at the idea that America was “so free”. His explanation, while having plenty wrong with it, is more reflective of observable reality than the uniform narrative Americans are told by their government.

    I’m not too terribly worried about American teenagers reading it and deciding that a life of committed Islamic fundamentalism is for them — I just don’t think the conditions are there to support that kind of thing being an attractive prospect — but I think learning to question imperial narratives, seek out primary sources, and consider the common humanity of people they’ve only known as caricatures are important steps in developing a historical materialist worldview.